Coaching Magazine

The Silent Sideline: Hidden Dangers of Coaches Ignoring Athletes

Linda Martindale

The Silent Sideline: Hidden Dangers of Coaches Ignoring Athletes

Linda Martindale

In the ever-changing and competitive world of sports, the relationship between a coach and an athlete is pivotal at every level from youth sports all the way to professional sports. While much attention is given to the Xs and Os, training techniques and performance strategies, the emotional and psychological support needed by all athletes is equally important. Ignoring athletes or the more updated term of “ghosting athletes” whether intentionally or inadvertently, can have profound negative effects that are often underestimated.

Reports of athletes feeling ignored or “unseen” by their coaches are becoming more common across youth, high school and college sports. Whether it’s limited communication, lack of feedback or outright neglect, the effects on student-athletes are profound. This issue has sparked concern among athletes, parents and sports psychologists, raising questions about the long-term impact on young athletes’ career and mental health.

The Long Term Impact of Athletes Feeling Ignored

Mental fitness coach and founder of Martindale Coaching, Linda Martindale, is a prominent advocate for integrating mental fitness practices into sports coaching. She sheds light on why this issue is more harmful than most expect.

“Sadly, I see athletes in my practice all the time who feel invisible to their coaches. It can be deeply damaging to an athlete’s mental fitness, not to mention their mental health,” says Martindale. “Athletes may start to question their abilities and worth, leading to increased performance anxiety and decreased confidence on the playing field.”

A troubling trend has emerged where some coaches are choosing to ignore their athletes rather than having the difficult conversations that need to be had. It is not a secret that the college transfer portals are overflowing and athletes and coaches alike are struggling. Leaving emails, text messages and voicemails unanswered is clearly not the answer. 

When younger athletes feel ignored by their coaches, it can lead to a cascade of psychological issues which can have lasting consequences. The sense of being undervalued or overlooked can significantly affect an athlete’s self-esteem and motivation. Sports, most people can agree, are supposed to provide the opposite effects.

Linda Martindale

Trust is the Foundation of a Successful Partnership

Trust between a coach and an athlete is the foundation of a successful partnership. When athletes feel ignored, this trust can erode, leading to a breakdown in communication and teamwork. Without the necessary feedback and engagement from their coach, athletes may struggle to identify areas for improvement or feel uncertain about their progress. 

According to the American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP), as many as 7 in 10 kids drop out of youth sports by age 13. We know that sports are an excellent way to stay active and have fun with friends, not to mention building self-esteem and learning cooperation with peers so dropping out is not the direction young athletes should be heading.

“Coaches are essential for providing constructive feedback and guidance, especially at critical times of development,” Martindale explains. “When athletes don’t receive this, they can feel lost and unsupported. Athletes who feel heard and understood by their coaches are better equipped to handle the pressures of competition.”

The impact of being ignored extends beyond the sports arena, affecting an athlete’s overall mental health. Feelings of isolation and neglect can contribute to more serious mental health issues such as depression and anxiety. Ignoring athletes can also have a ripple effect on the entire team. When some athletes feel neglected, it can create divisions within the team and foster a toxic environment.

Active Engagement is a Simple and Crucial Step

Active engagement and effective communication from coaches, and it could be as simple as a response to an email or text, is crucial in fostering a positive team environment where athletes feel heard and valued. By equipping coaches with the tools and techniques to communicate well, institutions can enhance athletic performance, build strong teams and support the overall well-being of their athletes. This can involve quick weekly check-ins, personalized feedback during practice, and showing genuine interest in the athlete’s development.

Former NCAA swimmer Sarah Thompson recounts her experience, stating, “When my coach started ignoring me, I felt lost and disconnected from the team. It became difficult to stay motivated and the sense of camaraderie we once had disappeared.”

“Having hard conversations with athletes can be difficult,” Martindale explains. “but giving honest feedback not only enhances performance but also builds a resilient and motivated athlete.”

Create a Culture of Transparency

Creating a culture of transparency and support within athletic programs will help foster a more positive and productive environment for all involved, including the coaching staff. Trust is a critical component of the coach-athlete relationship. When athletes feel ignored, the trust between them and their coach can deteriorate, affecting communication and team dynamics. This is especially important for athletes who are facing setbacks like injuries, lack of playing time or a decline in performance. Ignoring athletes during these important times can be devastating and coaches must understand the important role they play as athletes bounce back.

Recognizing the importance of being present and attentive can transform the coach-athlete relationship, leading to healthier, happier, and more successful athletes. The hidden dangers of ignoring athletes serve as a crucial reminder that effective coaching goes beyond the physical aspects of sports, encompassing the emotional and psychological well-being of athletes.

Get the best success strategies and tools delivered right to your inbox!

Scroll to Top

The coaching experts, knowledge and next-level developments to your inbox.

Your privacy is our highest priority. We will never sell or share your personal information.